Oetting Insurance Agency Inc
10848 Rose Avenue, Suite 2, New Haven, IN 46774
View this agency's profile to learn more about their services.
Loading...
City directory
New Haven households and business owners trust local agents to navigate carrier appetite shifts, underwriting requirements, and the claims process.
Compare local agents, coverage options, and specialties to find the right fit for your insurance needs.
10848 Rose Avenue, Suite 2, New Haven, IN 46774
View this agency's profile to learn more about their services.
Learn about insurance coverage options specific to New Haven residents.
New Haven home insurance averages $2,642/year. Learn about flood risks, historic home coverage, and how to save on premiums in Connecticut's second-largest city.
Yes, if you're anywhere near the Quinnipiac, Mill, or West Rivers. New Haven's flood risk comes primarily from these river systems, not just coastal storm surge. The Fair Haven neighborhood faces particularly high risk. Standard homeowners insurance excludes all flood damage, and flooding from rivers can be just as devastating as coastal flooding—August 2024's flash floods caused nearly $300 million in damage across Connecticut.
Connecticut ranks third-highest in the nation for auto insurance costs at an average of $2,815 annually. Contributing factors include high population density, expensive vehicle repairs, above-average medical costs, and higher claim frequencies in urban areas like New Haven. The state's no-fault requirements for uninsured motorist coverage also add to base costs.
Connecticut requires 25/50/25 liability coverage, which means $25,000 per person for bodily injury, $50,000 per accident for bodily injury, and $25,000 for property damage. You must also carry uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage at 25/50 limits. These minimums haven't changed for 2025, but most insurance professionals recommend significantly higher limits for adequate protection.
New Haven residents pay an average of $1,536 per year for flood insurance through the National Flood Insurance Program, which is above Connecticut's state average of $1,426. Your actual cost depends on your property's flood zone designation, elevation, construction date, and coverage amount. New Haven participates in FEMA's Community Rating System, which can provide premium discounts.
Starting July 1, 2026, insurance producers must inform homeowners and property insurance applicants in writing that flood coverage isn't included in standard policies and that separate coverage is available through NFIP or private insurers. This new requirement aims to prevent homebuyers from being blindsided by flood risk, particularly important in cities like New Haven with significant inland flood exposure.
Both approaches work, but local agents offer advantages in New Haven's complex insurance landscape. They understand neighborhood-specific flood risks, how Yale University affects rental property insurance, and can access multiple carriers through a single relationship. Online purchasing offers convenience and sometimes lower prices. Consider getting quotes both ways and comparing not just price but coverage quality and service access.
Stand out to local shoppers with your team, specialties, and business hours. Member agencies get priority placement and more features.
Join the network