Question 1

Does homeowners insurance cover tornado damage in Mattoon?

Accepted Answer

Yes, tornado damage is covered under standard homeowners insurance policies as windstorm coverage. Your policy should cover structural damage to your home, damage to your roof and siding, personal belongings, and additional living expenses if you need to live elsewhere during repairs. However, many policies include percentage-based wind/hail deductibles rather than flat amounts, which can result in higher out-of-pocket costs after a tornado.

Question 2

How much does home insurance cost in Mattoon, Illinois?

Accepted Answer

Home insurance in Coles County, where Mattoon is located, typically costs between $618 and $838 annually, or roughly $51 to $69 per month. This is significantly lower than Illinois's statewide average of $2,402 to $3,062 per year, primarily due to Mattoon's lower median home values and property risks. Your specific rate will depend on your home's value, age, construction type, coverage limits, and your claims history.

Question 3

Do I need flood insurance for my Mattoon home?

Accepted Answer

Standard homeowners insurance does not cover flooding, so if you're concerned about flood risk—particularly if you live near Lake Paradise or in a low-lying area—you should consider purchasing separate flood insurance. The average cost of flood insurance in Illinois is $87 monthly or $1,039 annually. Even if you're not in a designated flood zone, heavy rains accompanying severe storms can cause flooding that your standard policy won't cover.

Question 4

What special insurance considerations apply to Lake Paradise properties?

Accepted Answer

Lake Paradise waterfront properties typically need additional coverage for docks, boat lifts, and seawalls, which may be covered under your policy's "other structures" provision but often at limited amounts (typically 10% of dwelling coverage). Lakefront homes may also face higher wind/hail deductibles or specific exclusions related to water damage. It's essential to work with an agent familiar with waterfront properties to ensure adequate coverage for these specialized structures and exposures.

Question 5

Should I choose replacement cost or actual cash value coverage?

Accepted Answer

Replacement cost coverage is generally recommended because it pays to replace damaged items with new equivalents without deducting for depreciation. Actual cash value coverage deducts depreciation, which can leave you thousands of dollars short when replacing major items like roofing or HVAC systems. While replacement cost coverage costs slightly more in premiums, it provides significantly better financial protection when you need to file a claim.

Question 6

How can I lower my home insurance premium in Mattoon?

Accepted Answer

You can reduce your premium by installing security systems, smoke detectors, and protective devices (typically saving 5-15%), maintaining a claim-free record, bundling home and auto insurance, improving your credit score, and shopping around for competitive rates. Additionally, choosing a higher deductible and ensuring you're not over-insured based on your home's actual replacement cost can lower your premium. Given that Coles County rates are already below the state average, these discounts can make coverage even more affordable.

Insurance Agents in Mattoon, Illinois (IL)

Insurance agencies serving Mattoon

Dick Butler & Associates Inc

Dimond Bros Insurance, LLC

Insurance Agents in Mattoon, Illinois (IL)

Insurance agencies serving Mattoon

Dick Butler & Associates Inc

Dimond Bros Insurance, LLC

First Mid Insurance Group

First Mid Insurance Group Macomb

Gardner-Whitworth Ins. Group

Insurance Guides for Mattoon

Home Insurance in Mattoon, Illinois

Auto Insurance in Mattoon, Illinois

Frequently asked questions